Thursday, December 06, 2007

the tourist bashing trap

i'm kind of over all of the tourist bashing that is so prevalent amongst the denizens of this city, especially at this time of year. yeah sure, i myself have sort of engaged in the same shooting fish in a barrel sport on occasions, but only when i felt certain injustices were being blatantly perpetrated upon me/us, such as when my dear local starbucks has been defiled by eurotrash while the line is being held up by the unfortunate souls for whom deciphering a starbucks menu is akin to reading the mandarin translation of war and peace.

there was a story in the weds. ny post pertaining to the onslaught of tourist season in nyc. sort of a survival guide for locals. the piece was filled with many of the predictable cliches regarding new york city tourists.

"areas like Rockefeller Center or Fifth Avenue, where out-of-towners stroll, be-fannypacked, holding hands and walking four-abreast across the street. They shuffle down the sidewalk, stopping midstride to gawk upward and point . . . at what, we have no idea."

the article was accompanied by this photo of models posing as local tourists...



yeah, yeah, yeah, tourists are slow, often rotund and haven't lived here long enough to understand that the sidewalks are our freeways. we get it. but how many among us can say that we were never tourists to this city, specifically manhattan?

i don't have any census data to back this up, but i'd bet my left nut that less than 5% of the residents of manhattan that reside below 96th street were actually born and raised here. and let's face it, when tourists come to this city they're coming to see manhattan below 96th street. i don't think that i've ever heard of anyone coming here looking to explore the wondrous wilds of staten island or the bronx. so that tells me that most of the incessant bitching about people coming from other places to experience the wonders of this town are being done by people who have come from other places to experience the wonders of this town, albeit on a more permanent basis.

???

how soon we forget when it was we who were once the ones gawking up towards the sky in amazement, the ones walking very deliberately down the sidewalk with stars in our eyes, the ones smiling at each and every stranger we passed on the street, the ones actually initiating conversations with people on the subway.

personally, i kind of like it. when given the chance i enjoy stopping to ask people where they're from, what they plan on doing while they're here and what do they think of the city? it's actually quite refreshing. seeing the city through the eyes of others helps to remind me of all the things that i saw and felt when i first came here. in a way it's actually quite revitalizing. when you live here for a while you do, unfortunately, become stereotypically jaded. you take for granted the things that make this city what it is.

one of the happiest times of my life was during the holiday season of 2003 when i had family visit me here for the first time since my arrival. to be able to show them parts of the new york that they only knew through movies and other popular lore was great, but to get to show them MY new york, the historic neighborhood in which i lived, which at the time was the still semi-gritty lower east side, the quaint cafe where i got my coffee every morning pre-starbucks, the pizzeria where i went for late night slices served by a short, chubby italian man named sal, the arab deli at the corner that i would often call to have a sandwich and a soft drink delivered to my door at 4am, the bar where i drank copious amounts of alcohol while watching my beloved saints and LSU tigers with fellow louisiana transplants, the chinese laundry across the street that would pickup, wash and fold my laundry and return it to me within 3 hours for 5 bucks, was simply a most splendid time in my life.

i can also remember when a guy wearing a suit muttered "move your asses" as he proceeded to almost barrel one of them over as he was trying to get out of the stairway and how i felt so compelled to chase him down and punch him in his big, stupid face for doing so.

so all i'm asking, all i plea really, is that if you're reading this and you just so happen to reside in manhattan right now that you try to remember these times in your own life, even when you might be rushing to get to a meeting or a dinner or a movie, whatever, as you go about the course of your normal life. i'm occasionally guilty of it too. i often have to stop and check myself. simply taking a second to eavesdrop on one of their conversations will often suffice.

"wow mom! look, it's the empire state building!"

i find that such a thing is often kryptonite to the unintentional black-hearted facade of even the most jaded, asshole new yorker.


god bless america(especially new york city!)

where even the daughter of a former president and possible future one is forced to sit on the floor at starbucks...


via daily intelligencer via jezebel


"what do i gotta do here?"


hey remember that dude that busted into one of hillary clinton's campaign offices last week and took everyone hostage? well, guess what...he was only hoping that a police sharpshooter would take him out! the ny daily news had an interesting exclusive interview with the kook yesterday...

Leeland Eisenberg never imagined he'd shuffle into a prison visitors' room and give an interview days after taking hostages at Hillary Clinton's campaign office.

He thought he would be dead.

In fact, he ate a "last supper" at Fat Tony's Italian Grill on Main St. in Rochester, N.H., before crossing the street, bursting into the office and telling the seven people inside to hit the floor because he had a bomb.

"I had what I called my last supper. I had a rum and Coke and spaghetti and sausage," Eisenberg told the Daily News Tuesday in an exclusive interview.

And then, he said, he waited to die.

"I didn't surrender," said Eisenberg, 46, of Somersworth, N.H., adding that he hoped police would kill him in the standoff.

"I knew once the last hostage went out the door, there would be no reason for them to have restraint. I could see the sharp-shooter. He was all dressed in camouflage, and he had one of those laser lights on his rifle.

"I didn't have my hands up or nothing. I just walked toward the door, thinking, 'This is it, he'll take me out.' So I swing the door open, and he still didn't shoot me, and I'm like, 'What do I gotta do here?'

"My intent was never to hurt anyone. My intent was actually almost like a suicide by cop," he said. "But I wanted to make a message first."


read the whole astonishing thing here...

ny daily news story on leeland eisenberg


the district sleeps alone tonight by the postal service

there's something to be said for walking down the street on a cold winter night with the snow blowing in your face as this song plays in your ears...



Share on Facebook

24 comments:

Anonymous said...

Not to mention the billions of toursits dollars that continue to pour into that city each year that support the lifestyles of the people doing the bashing!

The Cajun Boy said...

@anon...agreed!!!

Ashley said...

So beautifully well said CB

Riley said...

When I've been to NYC, I've tried to fit in as best I can - moving quickly on the sidewalk, if I need or want to stop I moved out of the way, I tried not to gawk (too much). But it's hard. NYC is like another country for many of us - so different from the towns we come from. So thanks for being a little understanding. (That's the sweet Southern boy in you!)

And I think people who want to go by "suicide-by-cop" are the WORST cowards. If you want to kill yourself, then just do it yourself. Don't make somebody else do it for you!

Anonymous said...

As someone who visits New York from Alabama every year during the holidays to spend my hard earned money, I appreciate those thoughts. And can't gentleman offer Chelsea a chair?

NYCPonderings Chick said...

I do see your point about being nicer to tourists since they are people's moms and dads and yaddy yaddy ya.... but I beg, no more pictures on the subway! Why must anyone under the age of 30 insist their time in NYC must be spent taking pictures inside a subway car? I dont go to the suburbs and take pictures inside people's Dodge Neons.

Stephanie said...

I agree on all points but it still doesn't make it any less frustrating when I'm trying to walk down 5th Avenue to get to work.

Adrienne said...

Right on CB- I've been thinking those very same thoughts lately. I haven't even been living here for that long and I found myself already becoming a bit jaded about tourists- and then the other day as I was doing it I thought, hey they aren't that much different from me!

The Cajun Boy said...

@ashley...ty.

@riley...totally. just fucking kill yourself already. proves my point though that killing yourself takes much courage.

@ponderings...i do. take pictures of dodge neons that is.

@anon...i will offer chels a chair next time.

@adrienne...tourists are just like us, only slower!

Ben K. said...

I can truthfully state that I have never been a tourist in New York City. Born and raised south of 96th St. in Manhattan. Oh yeah.

The Cajun Boy said...

@ben k...well then you have a right to bitch i suppose.

silverb said...

My tourist days are murky. I got off the boat from Germany in the Brooklyn Navy Yard when I was two months old in the arms of my mom, so I guess you could call me an immigrant first. I have ushered my German relatives around and it is fun seeing the city through new sets of eyes.

Tourists dollars are great for the New York economy, but if they were supporting my lifestyle I'd be hanging with Oprah, not living like the middle-income editor I am.

I try to be nice to tourists, though, because it is so different and overwhelming sometimes. I like to give them good directions when they look lost or ask for them, but their slow-ass sidewalk hogging ways do grate on my nerves once in a while

Ha Ha Sound said...

Must disagree with you about the tourist thing. I think they forget that this is a living, breathing city where people have to get to places. Often very quickly. I feel like they make no effort to observe the customs of the city, which is something I always try to be conscious of when I travel.

Agreed about the 5% of people brought up in Manhattan, though. Have you ever met any of them? They're pretty much all nuts.

Kittie said...

Even though I'm a Bronxite (still NYC though but you're right, no one's saying "oooh, vacation to the boogie down!!"), I have always been nice to tourists - I feel bad when people huff & puff at them and make nasty comments as they dart around them (this is my coworker all the way - she is the biggest "in a rush" jaded NYer turned Pennsylvanian)....they are just trying to soak in and experience something that a lot of them will probably never see again and I hope, when I'm in some other big & fast-paced city, people are as polite to me when I am ooh-ing, ahh-ing and possibly lingering just a little too long for their patience.

On another note, I've lived in NYC my whole life, but you describe it as a place I've never been to been to before...you're so good Pony.

Ben K. said...

@cajun...I try not to bitch. The tourism dollars are wonderful. It's only the stopping at tops/bottoms of staircases that get to me. Otherwise, I think we all — natives and non-natives alike — stop to enjoy the sights now and then.

DrunkBrunch said...

You make such a good point. I live right around 96th Street and have to beg my friends to come uptown, because they think "there's nothing going on up there."

If they only knew!

Julie said...

Bravo, Caj. I'm not a New Yorker, but having lived and worked on a "tiny, tony East Coast island" for many years, the tourist bashing was the same, and fierce. Like you, though, their experiences always reminded me of the halcyon days of my first visit. I loved this post.

Anonymous said...

Cajun,

I don't want to jump to any conclusions but I'd be willing to guess that since you're a transplant you probably hang out with other transplants in a few select areas, LES, Williamsburg etc, like many transplants and long-term visitors do?

What you perhaps don't realize though, is that there are many more of us who were born and raised here (the natives) than there are transplants.

For example, just from DCP's data. Out of approximately 8 million who live in this city, around 4.3million were born in NYC and 8 other selected counties. basically, more than half of us are native New Yorkers!

About 40% or almost 3 million are foreign born, those from other countries.

The rest of the population is made up of those born in other states outside of our immediate metro area. A paltry 700,000 or so fit into your catagory, les than 10%.
are transplants from the midwest, California, Louisiana, etc. I know it's hard to believe if this is who you choose to hang out with or if you just haven't met many local but we do in fact far outnumber all of yous.

We won't even get into the composition of the other 14 million of so living in our 31 county metro area, minus the city.

Please understand and please don't take offense, but New York is still run by New Yorkers.

Take care! Jay from Stuy Town

The Cajun Boy said...

@haha...i disagree. i think most make the effort, it's just impossible to learn them all in the span of merely a few days.

@silverb...if there's one thing that grates on me, it's the walking 4 abreast at a snails pace. i have literally almost run people over at times.

@julie...cape cod? wait, that's not an island, is it?

@drunkbrunch...i say 96th because that about covers the guggenheim, which is about as far north as tourist attractions go. with the exception of tom's diner(the place from seinfeld) which is at broadway and 110 i think.

@kittie...i'm a wordy pony, aren't i?

@jay from stuy town...you'd be correct in just about all of your assumptions jay. no offense taken on anything. i do, however, plan to stay awhile.

Broke In Paradise said...

I have to agree more with ha ha sound on the tourist issue. But then...I agree with you too. The Southern in me is nice to tourists when I run into them, which is every 3.5 seconds...unless they are doing something rude or ignorant.
I spent my summers in NYC with family until I was about 13 though, so maybe thats why I can't ever recall gawking at skyscrapers. A friend that I took up with me to visit family last year did that, as it was her first time above the Mason-Dixon and I never laughed so hard in my life.

FunkyFrum said...

My husband grew up below 96th street, and whenever we go back, he likes to complain about New Yorkers. How is that for irony?

modelbehavior said...

empathy for tourists? You? Did I ever tell you about the southern women with me on the R train screaming 'whee' and 'giddy up' at the joy of riding the subway? Makes you appreciate life's simple pleasures.

Lisa M said...

Our tourists arrive in RV's and campers. We all bitch like crazy when we get stuck behind them on the highway. But then I take my kids swimming at the lake, where all the RV's are parked, and they are all out under the trees having picnics and swimming and it's not so bad. I spent a weekend visiting with a Russian family, newly moved to Seattle and seeing the sites east of the mountains, and had a great time. It's all about perspective.

Julie said...

Nantucket. Now I'm back in my home town in Upstate New York and guess what? not a lot of tourists ;)